“I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.”

Most students start their day with these words as they stand with their right hand over their chest. It’s just a simple daily ritual, right? Is it that simple? Now, the questions I am going to put forth are: Do you have to stand for the pledge? Why would you not want to?

The first question can be simply answered: No, you do not have to stand. According to the Clark County School District legal department, you have the right to sit quietly while the “Pledge of Allegiance” is being recited. There does seem to be the belief of several teachers and school officials that you have to stand. “You do not have to say it, but you must stand,” they often say. That is incorrect, though a popular myth. No school official can force or intimidate you into standing for the “Pledge;” that is a violation of your rights.

If a school official asks why, tell them that it is your right not to tell them why. That it is your personal business. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, you can keep it private. So, if you choose to, you may sit.

Keep in mind, though, that regardless of your stance on the “Pledge,” all students are required to conduct themselves in a respectful and considerate manner.

Now, on to the second of my questions. Why would you want to sit during the “Pledge”? Isn’t that disrespectful, unpatriotic, something a terrorist would do? NO! The reasons for sitting during the “Pledge” vary.

Some sit because of religion. Some religions do not allow you to pledge your allegiance to anything but God. Forcing these students to say the “Pledge” or stand to it would be like condemning their souls.

Another reason is that choosing not to say the “Pledge” can be a form of silent protest. Some people do not agree with some U.S. policies and choose this way to express their dissent. Sitting down gives Americans a way to express their feelings in a non-violent form.

Other reasons are simple, such as they do not yet know enough about America to pledge allegiance to it. Would you pledge allegiance to someone or something you knew little or nothing about?

There are many reasons not to say or stand for the “Pledge of Allegiance.” We all have our own beliefs, and they need to be respected. Just because you do not agree with something does not give you the right to step all over it. Remember you have rights; do not allow them be revoked, and allow others to protect their rights as well.

If you wish to sit during the “Pledge” and run into any sorts of problems no matter how little or how big, do not hesitate one second to seek help. Contact the Nevada Chapter of the ACLU or contact the Clark County School District; they are there to help you resolve your conflict.

-Return to February 2005 Issue-